Is it better to move house or extend

Should You Move Or Extend? The Pros And Cons

Posted by Craig | Updated July, 2024 | 5 Min Read Time

At a glance 

  • It ultimately comes down to a deeply personal decision whether to extend or move


In this article, you’ll find the following:

    • Considerations to take into account when making your decision
    • The pros and cons of both options 

When confronted with the need for more space in our homes, many of us find ourselves at a crossroads: to move or to extend? This dilemma often leads homeowners to evaluate the familiar mantra, “don’t move, extend,” considering how extending can offer the needed space without the upheaval of relocating.

It’s a weighty decision, requiring thoughtful consideration of several factors. Each option has its own set of advantages and drawbacks. To help you decide the best course of action, I’ve compiled a list of the pros and cons of both moving and extending your current property. 

A side angle photo of a resent ground floor extension

The decision between moving or extending is deeply personal and based on individual needs and circumstances.

Consider Future Plans, Budget and Emotional Attachment

What’s right for you? Is it time to extend or move?

Moving House - The Allure of a Fresh Start

Moving to a new house can be an exhilarating experience. It offers the chance for a complete change of scenery and a fresh start in a new community.

Let’s delve deeper into the advantages and disadvantages, the pros and cons of moving house which really make the difference. 

Pros Of Moving House

New Opportunites: Relocating to a new neighbourhood or even a different city can present new job opportunities, schools, and social circles

Tailored Space: If your current home layout doesn’t fit your needs, moving allows you to search for a property that better aligns with your specifications without the hassle of construction work.

Increased Property Value: If you’ve maintained your home well, you might be in a position to sell it at a profit, enabling you to invest in a bigger or better-situated property.

Cons Of Moving House

Costs: Moving house can be expensive. Between estate agent fees, stamp duty, and moving costs, the bills can quickly add up.

Emotional Strain: Leaving a home filled with memories can be emotionally taxing. Furthermore, the moving process itself – packing, unpacking, and setting up in a new place – can be stressful.

Potential Complications: he property market can be unpredictable. Your house may not sell as quickly as you’d like, or you might struggle to find your ideal new home within your budget.

Extending Your Current Home - Growing Where You're Based

Rather than seeking a new address, some choose to expand their current living space. This decision often comes down to the “extend or move” question, with many opting for the former to avoid the hassles and costs associated with moving. This can be achieved through a variety of means such as loft conversions, rear extensions, or even basement excavations.

A beautiful rear kitchen extension with modern decorating and styling

Pros Of Extending Your Home

Added Value: When done correctly, extensions can add significant value to your property. It’s a worthwhile investment that can offer returns when you decide to sell.

Customisation: Extending allows you to tailor your existing space precisely to your liking. Whether it’s a bigger kitchen, an extra bedroom, or a specialised workspace, the choice is yours.

No Need To Relocate: You can avoid the hassle and upheaval of moving. You’ll remain in the same neighbourhood, keeping the same neighbours, schools, and local amenities.

Cons Of Extending Your Home

Disruption: Construction can be disruptive. You’ll have to tolerate noise, mess, and potential complications that come with building projects.

However, the emphasis here is on ‘well-designed’ and ‘high-quality’. A rushed, poorly planned extension can detract rather than add value. Hence, it’s paramount to work with reputable professionals who can ensure the highest standards for your project.

Potential Overcapitalisation: There’s a risk of overcapitalising, which means spending more on the extension than what it adds to the property’s value. It’s essential to get expert advice and research before undertaking significant renovations.

Space Limitations: There’s only so much you can extend before running out of garden or plot space. This can limit the size and scope of your project.

We recommend reaching out to your local building authorities to obtain the precise requirements and regulations for your house extension, regardless of the style you envision, ensuring you have all necessary planning in place.

Conclusion: The Verdict

The decision between moving or extending is deeply personal and based on individual needs and circumstances. Here are some main points to keep in mind:

  1. Budget: Weigh the costs involved in both options. Sometimes it might be more economical to extend rather than incur the expenses of a move. However, if you’re looking at substantial extensions, moving might be the more cost-effective choice.


  1. Future Plans: Consider how long you plan to stay in your current property. If you’re planning on relocating in a few years, it might not make sense to invest in extensive renovations now.


  1. Emotional Attachment: If you’re deeply attached to your current home or neighbourhood, extending might be preferable. Conversely, if you’re craving change, relocating might be the best option.

Ultimately, the decision lies in what aligns best with your family’s needs, financial situation, and long-term goals. Whatever you choose, make sure it’s a choice you’ll be happy with for years to come.

Whether it’s the allure of a fresh start in a new home or the desire to mould your existing space into your dream dwelling, both options have their merits. Take your time, do your research, and most importantly, follow your heart and instincts.

If you are still interested in finding out more about house extensions, consider reading our blog on >> House extensions that don’t require planning permission


Craig Smith

The founder of CJ Smiths Construction Company for over 14+ years and a proud citizen of St Albans City.

Table of Contents

Struggling To Find A Reliable Builder For Your House Extension?

Scan the code